Underwood made her grand return to American Idol after winning so many years ago, but fans noticed that the premiere made too much of a big deal about it. The singer even played C

The latest run of American Idol has nudged judge Luke Bryan into the spotlight for a slightly quirky reason – viewers clocked an amusing peculiarity about him that persisted throughout the Season 23 debut.

American Idol judges Luke Bryan, Lionel Richie, and Carrie Underwood faced off in a heated edition of the Name That Song Challenge on the March 5 episode of The Tonight Show. Bryan and Richie competed against Underwood and Jimmy Fallon,